Two small sailboats on a dark navy sea under storm clouds, one holding course toward a break of gold light on the horizon, the other heading toward a rocky shore

The Adviser Effect: Why Your Behavior Matters More Than Your Fund

A CFA’s five-part case for what advice is really for, with Nick Murray’s verdict and what I see from my side of the desk.

Prefer to watch? See the video version on YouTube.

About the author

David Berkowitz, known as Berk, founded ValueAligned Partners, LLC in 2002, which does business as VAP Wealth Advisors. He has spent forty years in markets. He started at Woodward and Associates, a hedge fund, where he worked as trader, analyst, and CFO. He studied value and quality investing at Columbia Business School. At Stern Stewart, the firm that created EVA, he consulted to large corporations adopting value-based management, working with boards, executives, and operating managers. For more than twenty years he managed a tax-conscious portfolio for a single family office. He now manages separately managed accounts of quality businesses for families, and publishes free investing education at Berk on Value.

Picture two people who buy the same fund on the same day. The market drops. One holds and reaches her goal. The other sells near the low, misses the recovery, and never gets there. Odiri Oginni, CFA, sums it up in one line: “The product was identical. The market experience was identical. The outcome was not.”1

That scene opens Oginni’s recent piece for the CFA Institute’s Enterprising Investor blog, and it is the best short case I have read for what a financial advisor is actually for. The framework below is his, including the name he gives it, The Adviser Effect, and its five capabilities. I have marked where I add my own experience and where I bring in Nick Murray, the writer who taught me more about investor behavior than anyone else.

The gap nobody puts on a fund fact sheet

Oginni’s core argument is that the industry has spent decades measuring products: funds, managers, alpha, benchmarks, assets under management. Those numbers matter, he writes, but they do not tell you whether the investor ended up better off. Behavioral finance, from Daniel Kahneman and Richard Thaler onward, has shown why. Loss aversion, overconfidence, herding and recency bias push people to buy after the good news and sell during the scary news.1

The research firm DALBAR tracks that gap every year. In 2024, its study found the average equity investor earned 16.54%, while the S&P 500 returned 25.02%. Same market, same year. DALBAR calls that difference an investor performance gap.2

Vanguard has tried to put a number on what closing that gap can be worth. In its Advisor’s Alpha research, the firm writes that “behavioral coaching may add 100 to 200 bps in net return,” or 1 to 2 percentage points, and that discipline and guidance “could be the largest potential value-add of the tools available to advisors.” Vanguard is careful about what the number means. The gain “should not be viewed as an annual value-add but is likely to be intermittent,” showing up mostly during periods of market stress or euphoria, and the actual value “may vary significantly, depending on clients’ circumstances.”3 It is an estimate for advisors in general, not a measure of any one advisor, me included.

Oginni’s way of saying it: investors are often not defeated by markets. They are defeated by their reactions to markets.

A switchback trail climbing steadily up a green mountainside at dawn, while a straight shortcut below ends at a cliff edge
AI-generated image.

Nick Murray put it more bluntly

Murray, who has spent decades teaching advisors, has been making Oginni’s point for years. His version, from a 2011 talk to financial planners in the UK: “The dominant determinant of real life returns and outcomes is not investment performance, it’s investor behaviour.”4

In Simple Wealth, Inevitable Wealth, his book written for investors, it reads: “Wealth isn’t primarily determined by investment performance, but by investment behavior.”5

He puts a number on the advisor’s side of it, too. On Morningstar’s The Long View in 2025, Murray said 85 to 90% of an advisor’s job is managing that behavior: keeping the client acting on the plan instead of reacting to the market. In a bear market, he said, that is close to the whole job, and he called it the highest-value service an advisor provides.6

“Oh, by the way, you will never be able to do this alone.”

Nick Murray, on the message under every page of his book

That line comes from Murray’s 2024 conversation with Josh Brown and Michael Batnick on The Unlock. He told them the book works on two levels. On the surface it tells you what to do: own equities, make a plan, keep adding, rebalance. Underneath, almost every other sentence carries that warning.7

My own shorthand: a good advisor is about 10% investment manager and 90% behavioral coach. Markets are simple. People are not.

Oginni’s five capabilities, and what each looks like in practice

Oginni names five capabilities that separate advisors who improve outcomes from advisors who simply process transactions.1 Each heading and its core idea below is his. The second half of each section is mine.

1. Creating understanding

Oginni: People cannot make good decisions about investments they do not understand. Good advisors trade sophistication for clarity, and understanding lowers uncertainty and builds confidence.

What I add: The clearest test I know is Murray’s. Think of the companies your family deals with every day: the bank, the phone in your pocket, the razor, the paper towels. If the stock market fell by half tomorrow, would you stop using any of them? Of course not. Yet when prices fall, people head for the exits as if the businesses had stopped existing. Murray asks clients to stop seeing themselves as players in what he calls “that hissing, writhing bag of poisonous snakes called the stock market” and start seeing themselves as owners of businesses.6 In my practice, understanding means you can explain in a sentence what each business you own does and how it makes money.

2. Managing investor emotions

Oginni: Volatility is certain and panic is common. During uncertainty the advisor acts as an emotional stabilizer, and talking a client out of one panic decision may be worth more than any portfolio change. That is why he calls behavioral coaching one of the most important skills in modern advice.

What I add: We have a name for that panic decision. We call it the Big Mistake: selling in a decline and turning a temporary drop into a permanent loss. One panic sale at the bottom can undo a decade of good decisions. Murray describes the moment better than anyone. The client is frightened, and the advisor says: “Stand fast. Turn off CNBC. Log out of your account. Keep looking in my eyes. Don’t look to the left or the right. This is going to pass. I can’t tell you how. I can’t tell you when. I can just tell you that this too shall pass.”7 At VAP, coaching is not an add-on. It comes with the relationship: phone calls, texts, whatever the moment needs.

A white lighthouse on a rocky point at night casting a steady gold beam across a rough navy sea
AI-generated image.

3. Connecting investments to goals

Oginni: His line here is one I will be borrowing: “Investors do not buy mutual funds.” What they are buying is retirement security, college for the kids, independence, peace of mind. When people know why they are investing, they are more likely to stay put when it gets hard.

What I add: Investments fund the plan. They are not the plan. The goals are usually concrete: the staircase lift, the wedding, the camper, the grandchild’s tuition. When a client calls in a decline, the most useful thing I can do is reread the plan we wrote together and ask whether any of those goals has actually changed. In my experience, what has usually changed is the mood, not the goals.

4. Building trust through transparency

Oginni: Investors do not expect certainty. They expect honesty. Advisors who explain the risks before the trouble arrives build stronger relationships and more resilient clients.

What I add: Murray tells new clients on day one: “About every five years during your equity investing career, about a third of your capital is going to appear to disappear.”6 Notice the words appear to disappear. A decline you were warned about feels like weather. One you were not warned about feels like a betrayal. The other line I keep in front of clients: volatility is not risk. Permanent loss is risk.

5. Ensuring suitability

Oginni: A suitable investment with moderate returns often beats an unsuitable one with higher expected returns. Recommendations have to fit the investor’s goals, risk tolerance, time horizon, liquidity needs and level of understanding.

What I add: This is where Murray and I part ways a little, and where suitability does real work. Murray is comfortable owning the whole market through broad funds. I prefer owning individual quality businesses directly. That choice has its own risk: a single company can stumble in ways a broad fund spreads out, and direct ownership without discipline is how people blow up. So the behavior rules come first. If owning single stocks would tempt you to trade, that is a suitability answer, and the right one for you may be Murray’s. Liquidity counts too. Murray’s own rule is to enter retirement with about two years of living expenses in cash so a bad stretch early on never forces a sale.6 For people near retirement, a reserve like that can make it easier to hold through a decline, though it depends on your spending, your other income and how long a decline lasts, and cash earns less over time. It may not fit someone with a short horizon or little room in the budget. This is general education, not a recommendation for your situation.

Does AI make the advisor obsolete?

Oginni takes this on directly, and I agree with his answer. Technology can supply information, analyze portfolios and suggest products. What it cannot easily replace is trust, judgment, empathy and the ability to help someone decide during uncertainty. He expects advisors to compete less on access to information and more on improving outcomes.1

From where I sit, that is already happening. Research that once took a team now takes an afternoon, and I use these tools every day to study the businesses we own. Knowledge has become something you can buy. Composure is not. I don’t expect software to sit with a frightened client at 2 a.m. while the screen is red.

A wooden desk late at night lit by a brass lamp, with a closed notebook, a pen, a cup of tea and a phone, a city window behind
AI-generated image.

The real measure

Oginni closes with the question I think every advisor should be judged on. The question is not what return the fund produced. It is whether the investor reached a better outcome. If yes, the advice did its job.1

Good advice has limits, and it is fair to name them. An advisor can be wrong. A plan you hold through a decline can still be down for a long stretch, and no one can promise when a recovery comes. What coaching can do is lower the odds of the one decision that turns a temporary decline into a permanent loss: the sale that did not need to happen.

Murray gave me the behavior. Oginni gave it a framework and a name. Good products matter, but a product only works for the person who can stay with it.

Get the next one in your inbox.

Plain-English notes on owning quality businesses and staying the course, a few times a month.

Subscribe

Notes

  1. Odiri Oginni, CFA, “Why Financial Advisers Matter More Than Investment Products,” Enterprising Investor, CFA Institute Research and Policy Center, September 23, 2026. The Adviser Effect and its five capabilities are the author’s framework, summarized here with attribution.
    Link. ↩
  2. DALBAR, 2025 Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior, press release, March 31, 2025. Average equity fund investor return versus the S&P 500 for calendar 2024.
    Link. ↩
  3. Francis M. Kinniry Jr., Colleen M. Jaconetti, Michael A. DiJoseph, David J. Walker and Maria C. Quinn, “Putting a value on your value: Quantifying Vanguard Advisor’s Alpha,” Advisor’s Alpha Perspectives, The Vanguard Group, July 2022. Behavioral coaching module, p. 17; caveats from the paper’s introduction and Figure 1 note. Vanguard’s estimate for advisors in general, not a measure of any particular advisor.
    Link. ↩
  4. Financial Planning Today, “Investment guru Murray urges IFP delegates to concentrate on investor behaviour,” report on the IFP Conference, October 5, 2011.
    Link. ↩
  5. Nick Murray, Simple Wealth, Inevitable Wealth, as quoted in Ben Carlson, “Book Review: Simple Wealth, Inevitable Wealth,” A Wealth of Common Sense, May 3, 2014.
    Link. ↩
  6. Morningstar, The Long View, episode 329, “Nick Murray: The Investor Is Hardwired to Be His Own Worst Enemy,” August 12, 2025.
    Link. ↩
  7. Ritholtz Wealth Management, The Unlock, “The Value Proposition of a Financial Advisor With Nick Murray,” Josh Brown and Michael Batnick, May 2024.
    Link. ↩

Important Disclosures

This content is produced by David Berkowitz under ValueAligned Partners, LLC, DBA VAP Wealth Advisors (“VAP Wealth Advisors”), an independent marketing brand, and is provided for general educational and informational purposes only. It is not, and should not be construed as, personalized investment, legal, tax, or accounting advice, nor an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security.

No advisory relationship. Viewing, reading, or interacting with this content does not create an investment-adviser, attorney-client, or accountant-client relationship. David Berkowitz is an investment adviser representative registered with Savvy Advisors, Inc. (“Savvy”), and all investment advisory services he provides are offered through Savvy. Investment advisory services are offered only through a written agreement with Savvy. ValueAligned Partners, LLC, DBA VAP Wealth Advisors, is an independent marketing brand used for advertising and marketing purposes only; ValueAligned Partners, LLC and Savvy are not related or affiliated. Additional information is available in Savvy Advisors’ Form ADV Part 2A and Form CRS at adviserinfo.sec.gov.

Not legal or estate-planning advice. David Berkowitz is not an attorney, and VAP Wealth Advisors does not practice law, draft legal documents, or provide legal opinions. Any discussion of wills, trusts, powers of attorney, beneficiary designations, or other estate-planning topics is general education only. You should consult a licensed attorney in your state before drafting, signing, or relying on any estate-planning document.

Not tax or accounting advice. David Berkowitz is not a CPA or Enrolled Agent, and VAP Wealth Advisors does not prepare tax returns or provide tax-return preparation services. Any discussion of tax topics is general education intended to help you understand tax-planning concepts and coordinate with your CPA or tax preparer. You should consult a qualified tax professional regarding your specific situation before acting on anything discussed here.

No guarantees; investment risk. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of, and does not guarantee, future results. Forward-looking statements are opinions as of the date recorded and are subject to change without notice.

Sources and third-party content. Links, tickers, and third-party materials are provided for convenience and do not constitute an endorsement. VAP Wealth Advisors is not responsible for the content of third-party sites.

Positions. David Berkowitz, his clients, employees, and family may own the stocks mentioned in this content. He is under no obligation to update the content or to disclose any future purchases or sales of those stocks.

All advisory services are offered through Savvy Advisors, Inc. (“Savvy Advisors”), an investment advisor registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”). Savvy Wealth Inc. (“Savvy Wealth”) is a technology company and the parent company of Savvy Advisors. Savvy Wealth and Savvy Advisors are often collectively referred to as “Savvy”.

David L Berkowitz is an investment advisor representative registered with Savvy Advisors, Inc. (“Savvy”). All investment advisory services offered by David L Berkowitz are offered through Savvy. ValueAligned Partners, LLC (also doing business as VAP Wealth Advisors) is an independent marketing brand name used by David L Berkowitz for advertising and marketing purposes only. ValueAligned Partners, LLC and Savvy are not related or affiliated. For more information about Savvy, please visit our website at savvywealth.com/advisor.

author avatar
David Berkowitz CIO
I’m Berk — Investor, Educator, and Owner. For 40 years I’ve helped families think like owners and invest in great companies. Earlier in my career I was head trader for a $250 million hedge fund, advised Fortune 500 boards and C-level executives and taught 10,000 of their employees at multi-billion-dollar companies, and trained non-financial employees in value-based management.

Share the Post Here

Related Posts

Follow Us Here

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Free Checklist kit

Estate Planning Checklist Kit

Take charge of your legacy with our expert-designed Estate Planning Checklist Kit! This free resource simplifies estate planning, empowering you to create a personalized plan to protect your family and assets. With clear, actionable guidance, you’ll eliminate confusion and take control of your future.

Verified by MonsterInsights